His loss told us what we had


Quick Links

1995, 1996, 1997

1998, 1999, 2000

2001, 2002, 2003

2004, 2005, 2006

2007, 2008, 2009

2010, 2011

Category: Profiles 01 Apr 07


I never felt as West Indian as I did when the voices of the Lydian singers soared and dipped, a chorus of angels so pure, so clear, that I thought that someone had put on a high tech doctored CD, until you saw their lips move.


The tears welled and wobbled, turning the hall into an underwater scene as Pat Bishop conducted singers, piano, tassa drummers and a ballet dancer (moving with the grace of a bele dancer recalling Africa) orchestrating our forebears‚ continents with a seamless swoop of her arms.


I have battled and resisted these islands for years, an immigrant split between continents of Asia, Europe and the Americas, at times felt as forlorn as if I were dropped in the sea in between.


I couldn’t reconcile initially, the rigid formal structured life of India, the extreme politeness, the landmines posed by having a Muslim mother and Hindu father, there, with the ease with which West Indians slip on the skins, names, cultures of other continents. How a judge can sip cocktails in the afternoon and end his night drinking a Carib with a construction worker on a road side.


India belongs to my childhood. What’s left of me belongs here, was fed by this place, grew here, will probably die here.


In that large hall in UWI, 16 years of my working life swam around me: colleagues, professionals, journalists, trade unionists, artists, writers and academics.


I was in a place where I knew almost everybody’s name. No stranger now.


Looking at the Tapia flag covering Lloyd Best’s coffin, singers swaying as naturally as bamboos, a hall full of people I respect, it was only in loss that I knew what we all had.


Mimic men


The elegant dancer in black, moving bird-like on the stage, now stomping, now flying, performing a timeless, universal ritual of mourning, gesturing at a dying age,


I looked at Arthur NR Robinson in the front row, and felt something like love for this man, who I knew as “Uncle” growing up in Tobago, and whose hands when I held them after the funeral felt cool to the touch, who took a gun in his mouth for this country during the attempted coup of 1990.


I remembered David Rudder and Peter Minshall making us weep and celebrate through song and mass, immortalising us with Tan Tan and Saga Boy, rallying us around the West Indies, but almost silenced by our emerging mindless brutality.


Rudder migrated. Minshall hunkering down.


Journalist Raoul Pantin, known for his columns but whose poetry, as brilliant as Walcott’s, eerily quiet. Wayne Brown and Dennis Solomon, migrated in a fog of disappointment; Frank Rampersad, George John, and now Best dying like that.


As the dancer pounds the stage, she expresses our national tragedy of not recognising what was fine in us, and going for the tinsel that gets discarded like a carnival costume.


Men like Lloyd Best, and men and women who loved him in and out of that hall (sadly, few MPs), take the discarded strands of continents that we are, polish and weave them, hold up damaged bits so we could fix them, give us forgotten slaves and indentured labourers, back to ourselves, whole.


Without them we would be floating between continents, standing on shifting sand, onlookers, and mimic men in an American reality TV show.


Better wrap our arms around them now, as we don’t want to make the same mistake again. Not knowing what we’ve got till it’s gone.


horizontal rule



All Articles Copyright Ira Mathur